What are you actually looking for when you hire someone? It's easy to start with a title, a list of requirements, and the person who used to sit in that seat. It's harder to step back and ask what the business needs now. The same problem can show up when we're looking for work: we know the title we want, but we haven't made it clear what we could help someone accomplish.
On The Matthew Byrd Podcast, I talked with Jessica Cafferty, founder and president of RNG Group and board chair of the Idaho Technology Council. We covered recruiting, entrepreneurship, and the way she thinks about her own business. What connects those subjects is the importance of listening closely enough to understand the situation before deciding what to do. That matters on either side of a hiring conversation.
Start, then listen to the market
That willingness to listen and adjust showed up in her own business, too. When Jessica started recruiting, she initially thought she wouldn't focus on IT because there were already people doing that work. Then her early clients asked for it, and the first ten roles her company filled were technology-related. She had a direction, but she also paid attention to what people needed. We can do the same when a plan meets the actual work: ask what we're learning before deciding the original idea has to stay exactly as it was.
Define success before filling the seat
Jessica used the example of an accountant leaving to explain how quickly a company can rush into replacing a role. Before putting the same job back on the market, she suggested asking why the person left, what other people on the team can take on, and whether the work should be organized differently. Her question was practical: "If in a year we hire the perfect person, what are they doing?" Answering that gives you something more useful than a familiar job description. It helps you explain the contribution you're hiring for and recognize whether a candidate can make it.
Make your contribution easy to understand
The next part is making the contribution clear enough that someone else can understand it. Jessica described reading a resume full of language that made it difficult to tell what the person actually did, even though she thought they were probably good at their job. As she put it, "People care about the impact that you made at your previous position." A polished sentence doesn't help much if the reader still can't explain why your experience matters. What problem did you help solve, and what changed because you were involved?
That doesn't require making the work sound bigger than it was. It requires giving another person a clear way to understand it and a reason to ask you more. I talked about the effort involved in sorting through applications, and Jessica explained why her recruiting process still relies on reaching out to people individually. A real conversation gives both sides a chance to learn something the initial paperwork hasn't answered. The resume can open that conversation, but it shouldn't make someone work through a wall of jargon to find you.
Jessica also encouraged people to reach out to a company they're interested in, even when there isn't an exact role advertised. That isn't a promise that a business will create a job for you. It's a way to explain what you could contribute instead of waiting for the perfect posting to describe it first. If you're applying for something above or below your recent role, she suggested being clear about that, too. Explain why you're interested and how you're thinking about the fit, rather than leaving the other person to guess.
Build a business around your priorities
There's another definition of fit that can be easy to overlook: whether the work supports the life you want. Jessica talked about having once felt she needed to build a much larger company, then realizing that wasn't the version of success she wanted. She described getting excited when her team members earned enough through their work to buy a car or a home. She also spoke about her children being her biggest priority and being clear about how that affects her availability. The point was understanding what she was building the business to make possible.
Jessica connected those choices to one of her values: "Integrity means doing what you say you're gonna do." If you say family matters most, what does that mean for the expectations you set at work? If you want a team people can rely on, are you making room to understand their needs and communicate your own? We don't all need the same schedule or the same size business. We do need to be honest about what success means to us, because that changes the roles, relationships and responsibilities we're willing to take on.
Turn what you hear into action
Near the end, our conversation came back to what happens after listening. Jessica said, "Being able to actually execute really is a differentiator as well." You can agree with a useful idea and still go back to doing everything the same way. A practical next step might be rewriting a role around its intended result, making your experience easier to explain, or having a clearer conversation about how you want to work. Listening gives you something to act on; the value comes from putting it into practice.
That brings us back to the question of what you're actually looking for. A better hire, a more useful introduction, or a business that fits your priorities starts with understanding the situation well enough to make a thoughtful choice. Jessica's examples give us several places to begin. We can ask a better question, listen to the answer, and change what we do with it.
Catch the full conversation on YouTube, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify: Put the Human Back in Hiring | Recruiting & Career Growth with Jessica Cafferty. You'll also hear Jessica's perspective on AI skills, community and learning with other entrepreneurs. We talk about the Idaho Technology Council and the importance of asking for help as a business owner.